Distinguishing Knowledge Impact from Citation Impact: A Methodology for Analysing Knowledge Impact for the Literature Review Genre

G. Schryen, G. Wagner, A. Benlian, Distinguishing Knowledge Impact from Citation Impact: A Methodology for Analysing Knowledge Impact for the Literature Review Genre, 2020.

Download
OA 487.35 KB
Working Paper | English
Author
; ;
Abstract
The scientific impact of research papers is multi-dimensional and can be determined quantitatively by means of citation analysis and qualitatively by means of content analysis. Accounting for the widely acknowledged limitations of pure citation analysis, we adopt a knowledge-based perspective on scientific impact to develop a methodology for content-based citation analysis which allows determining how papers have enabled knowledge development in subsequent research (knowledge impact). As knowledge development differs between research genres, we develop a new knowledgebased citation analysis methodology for the genre of standalone literature reviews (LRs). We apply the suggested methodology to the IS business value domain by manually coding 22 LRs and 1,228 citing papers (CPs) and show that the results challenge the assumption that citations indicate knowledge impact. We derive implications for distinguishing knowledge impact from citation impact in the LR genre. Finally, we develop recommendations for authors of LRs, scientific evaluation committees and editorial boards of journals how to apply and benefit from the suggested methodology, and we discuss its efficiency and automatization.
Publishing Year
LibreCat-ID

Cite this

Schryen G, Wagner G, Benlian A. Distinguishing Knowledge Impact from Citation Impact: A Methodology for Analysing Knowledge Impact for the Literature Review Genre.; 2020.
Schryen, G., Wagner, G., & Benlian, A. (2020). Distinguishing Knowledge Impact from Citation Impact: A Methodology for Analysing Knowledge Impact for the Literature Review Genre.
@book{Schryen_Wagner_Benlian_2020, title={Distinguishing Knowledge Impact from Citation Impact: A Methodology for Analysing Knowledge Impact for the Literature Review Genre}, author={Schryen, Guido and Wagner, Gerit and Benlian, Alexander}, year={2020} }
Schryen, Guido, Gerit Wagner, and Alexander Benlian. Distinguishing Knowledge Impact from Citation Impact: A Methodology for Analysing Knowledge Impact for the Literature Review Genre, 2020.
G. Schryen, G. Wagner, and A. Benlian, Distinguishing Knowledge Impact from Citation Impact: A Methodology for Analysing Knowledge Impact for the Literature Review Genre. 2020.
Schryen, Guido, et al. Distinguishing Knowledge Impact from Citation Impact: A Methodology for Analysing Knowledge Impact for the Literature Review Genre. 2020.
Main File(s)
File Name
Access Level
OA Open Access
Last Uploaded
2020-05-19T15:09:28Z


Link(s) to Main File(s)
Access Level
Restricted Closed Access

Export

Marked Publications

Open Data LibreCat

Search this title in

Google Scholar